Would an unfinished software app need to be disclosed in a Chapter 7 Bankruptcy?

In the context of a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, disclosure requirements are stringent, and failure to disclose assets properly can have serious consequences. If an unfinished software application is part of an individual’s or business’s property, it would need to be disclosed, regardless of whether it is fully developed, functional, or not currently generating income.

Legal Obligation to Disclose All Assets

Under U.S. bankruptcy law, the debtor is required to disclose all assets in the bankruptcy petition, including tangible and intangible property. A Chapter 7 bankruptcy aims to liquidate a debtor’s non-exempt assets to repay creditors. Intangible assets can include things like intellectual property, unfinished software, patents, and trademarks. Even if the software is unfinished or not generating income, it is still considered property of the debtor, and failure to disclose it could be considered fraudulent.

The Bankruptcy Code (11 U.S.C. § 521(a)(1)) explicitly requires the debtor to disclose any assets, debts, and sources of income. If the debtor fails to disclose a software app—whether it’s incomplete or still under development—this omission could complicate the bankruptcy process and potentially result in severe penalties, including the dismissal of the bankruptcy case, denial of discharge, or even criminal charges for bankruptcy fraud.

Types of Assets in Bankruptcy

In a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, assets are divided into two categories: exempt and non-exempt. Generally, tangible assets such as real estate, vehicles, and personal items are easier to evaluate in terms of value. Intangible assets like an unfinished software application, however, may require specialized knowledge to assess the value or potential revenue of the software project once completed.

For the debtor, an unfinished software app might be non-exempt property (which would typically need to be sold off to repay creditors), but there may be situations where the app could be considered exempt depending on the nature of its development, any agreements or rights related to it, and whether it is still in the early stages. The value placed on the app would be determined by the bankruptcy trustee, but intellectual property rights generally need to be disclosed even if they have minimal or no current market value.

Potential Issues with Undisclosed Assets

Failure to disclose the unfinished software app could result in several consequences:

1. Loss of Bankruptcy Discharge: The debtor could face the loss of the ability to have certain debts forgiven if it’s discovered that they deliberately withheld assets.
2. Criminal Penalties: Intentionally concealing assets can result in criminal charges for bankruptcy fraud under 18 U.S.C. § 152.
3. Dismissal of the Case: The bankruptcy petition could be dismissed entirely if the court finds that there has been a failure to disclose all assets properly.
4. Trustee Scrutiny: Even if there is no intentional concealment, the trustee may investigate any potential assets that appear to be unlisted, and may seek the appointment of a special counsel to determine whether there was intentional fraud.

Intellectual Property as an Asset

An unfinished software app may still qualify as intellectual property (IP), which can hold potential value. Intellectual property assets like patents, copyrights, and trademarks must be disclosed because these represent ownership rights that could be liquidated in bankruptcy to pay creditors. In fact, the value of the software might not be easily quantifiable, and it could depend on future profitability. This could include the potential to finish, sell, or license the software. Even if the software project is incomplete, the intellectual property involved, such as the underlying code or design, could hold significant value.

The U.S. Copyright Office provides a way to register and track software rights. If the debtor has obtained IP protection for the software, that would definitely need to be disclosed. Bankruptcy courts often look at the current market value and potential income when determining the fair market value of software projects.

Disclosures and Bankruptcy Schedules

When filing for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, the debtor fills out schedules that detail all assets and liabilities. On Schedule A/B, the debtor is required to list all property they own, including intellectual property and intangible assets like software development projects. On Schedule C, the debtor may claim exemptions to try and protect certain assets from liquidation, though many IP assets may not qualify for exemptions unless they fit into specific criteria.

Some parts of an unfinished software app, such as the code, documentation, or future revenue streams, may be worth liquidating, but failure to disclose them properly could lead to complications. The trustee, who will manage the bankruptcy process, may look into the debtor’s finances more deeply if there is suspicion that assets were left off the disclosure forms.

Practical Steps

1. Document the Software’s Value: It may be beneficial to get an expert valuation of the software’s development potential, as an intellectual property valuation could help in determining whether the asset has market value in the future.
2. Disclose the Software App: The debtor should include details of the app in the bankruptcy schedules, even if it is unfinished. Full transparency is essential.
3. Consult a Bankruptcy Attorney: A bankruptcy attorney will help ensure that all assets, including unfinished software, are disclosed properly and provide legal advice about any potential impact of the app on the overall bankruptcy proceedings.

---

Additional Resources and References:

• U.S. Bankruptcy Code: 11 U.S.C. § 521(a)(1)
• Clio Legal Trends Report 2023: Clio Legal Trends Report
• U.S. Copyright Office: www.copyright.gov

To summarize, unfinished software apps must be disclosed in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy. These assets, even if incomplete or without current financial value, are still part of the debtor’s estate and must be reported during the bankruptcy process to avoid severe penalties and ensure compliance with legal obligations. Consulting an attorney is vital in navigating the disclosure of such assets.